Destiny Review

Destiny - Title Screen
Standard

In space, no one can hear you grind.

(Reviewed on Xbox One)

Destiny, the fantastical new always-online sci-fi shooter adventure dreamt up by the original Halo developer Bungie, along with publisher Activision, is a bit of a mixed bag. Despite all my own excited desperation to play it prior to launch, and the buzz and hype about it in the gaming press leading up to its release, I have to say that Destiny is one of the most disappointing games that I’ve played in quite some time. Yet, it’s also one of the most enjoyable; it’s a game that I can’t stop sinking hour after enjoyable hour into, blasting away aliens and greedily snatching up that precious loot they drop. In fact, even as I type this opening paragraph, I’m really having to fight the urge to go and fire up the Xbox right now and get back into the action.

It’s hard to say exactly what the ever-evolving future of Destiny will be; whether that’s with regard to how it appears now in this initial representation, or when it has presumably grown into a larger extended franchise further down the line. Indeed, Bungie have promised to curate and support the game and its universe over an impressive ten year period. However, from playing what’s on offer in the game’s debut form, Destiny doesn’t quite yet feel like the brave new world we all so desperately wanted it to be.

On one hand, it has the fantastic first person shooter gameplay that a longtime Bungie fan craves, but on the other, it’s without a story of any similar depth or quality to their previous legacy. It has compelling and addictive loot mechanics, inspired in part by games like Borderlands 2 and Diablo III, but, sadly, these become frustratingly chancey and ever more confusingly unreliable as you get towards the level-cap and end-game content. However, despite some major stumbles, the game’s core shooting mechanics combined with an impressive social shared world experience with a strong focus on co-operative play make for a winning combo.

In a galaxy, far far away…

Destiny - Planetary Map

Pick a planet…any planet.

Destiny‘s narrative set up is as follows. In the present day, Mankind discover an otherworldly being on the planet Mars, a giant white orb known as ‘The Traveller’. The discovery of The Traveller sparks off a golden age of technological innovation and scientific prosperity for humanity, and upon making its home in a low orbit in the Earth’s atmosphere like a giant pale disco ball, The Traveller accelerates our growth across the solar system; terraforming other planets, tripling the average human lifespan, improving our tech and other such flashy miracles that giant space ball deities tend to do. However, it’s not long before an evil force, imaginatively named ‘The Darkness’ (no, don’t worry, it’s not Justin Hawkins’ band), comes to wipe out The Traveller and humanity. Not good. The Traveller sacrifices itself and manages to save the last human city beneath it, where the remains of our civilisation are surviving, before going dormant.

Some time after this catastrophic collapse, the game kicks off for you, the player, when a ghost – a robotic AI machine created by The Traveller – revives your long dead body (this is never really explained anywhere, so just go with it for now), and sets you out on your adventure as a Guardian. The Guardians are special warriors that can wield The Traveller’s light – in other words, kick some major ass and, you know, save the galaxy along the way and whatnot. You shoot your way through the tutorial mission, and upon finding your first rickety wreck of a spaceship, you head out on your epic quest to save the last remnants of humanity and The Traveller from the evil forces of darkness that are drawing ever closer…

Is it a bird? Is it a plane?

Destiny - Titan and The Traveller

The Traveller, hovering in all its vaguely hinted at glory.

So what exactly is Destiny then I hear you ask? Is it a first person shooter? Is it an MMO? Hell, could it be an MMORPG? Is it none of these things and instead just a figment of our collective imaginations?

Let’s start by going over some of the basics. Bungie describe Destiny as a ‘shared world shooter’, so let’s break down what this phrase actually means. The game is an FPS – First Person Shooter – where the player controls their Guardian character from a first person perspective, as in games such as the Halo and Call of Duty series. The shared world part means that the game is built around social interactions with other players in the game world, much like an MMO or MMORPG. Examples of MMOs – Massively Multiplayer Online games – and MMORPGs – Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games – are games like World of Warcraft, The Elder Scrolls Online or Guild Wars; these are games in which the player builds and customises their personal character and plays online with other players in a persistent online space.

In MMOs/MMORPGs, players typically complete quests, go on raids, craft items and take part in many other activities, all the while grinding merrily away and levelling up their character to make them more powerful. While many MMO players do like to play solo, these are games in which co-operation with other players is highly encouraged, and in most cases, essential to progress through the game fully. Players in these games can team up and interact with each other, to explore and fight their way through areas together in PVE (Player Versus Enemy) modes and even fight against each other in specific PVP (Player Versus Player) zones if they so desire. The game world in which all these activities take place is a persistent online space, which can change over time, and react to each player’s presence on the fly.

Bungie certainly drew direct inspirations and influences from the structure of MMOs when developing Destiny, which, on the whole, work well; in fact it’s arguably more of an MMO than a FPS in some key ways. Before we go into what works well and what doesn’t, let’s talk about the Guardian classes.

Classically trained

Each player in Destiny gets to create their own unique guardian; the idea being that every new player brings their own superhero-like space demon slayer to the fray to save the galaxy as a collective. Your Guardian’s character choices are purely aesthetic ones – do you want to be male/female, have short hair/long hair, do you want to be a human, robot, or space elf etc. (I’ve got more to say on these races, and their lack of any real background shortly), – but your choice of class is important, as it influences what style of combat you’re going to be best suited to when the shooting starts. You’ve got three different classes to choose from when starting the game – Titan, Warlock or Hunter.

Destiny - Titan

Titan.

The trio of classes operate like the typical classes you’d find in an MMO/Action RPG; the Titan is your Tank unit, which is exactly what it sounds like – a well-armoured tough-as-nails brute. Titans can take a lot of damage and deal it out in large amounts as well, and they’re generally most useful at dealing with large groups of standard enemies using powerful area of effect attacks.

Destiny - Hunter

Hunter.

The Hunter is your long ranged high DPS (Damage Per Second) character, who typically attacks from range, favouring sniper rifles and scout rifles; they also have some nifty throwing knives and special grenades to fling about, as well as a powerful golden gun attack which let’s them inflict massive damage to enemies for a short period of time. Naturally, this makes them crucial to taking down tougher enemies and boss characters quickly.

Destiny - Warlock

Warlock.

Last, but certainly not least, the Warlock is a sort of mix between a support character and what’s known in these circles as a ‘glass cannon’ – ie. a character capable of very high damage output at the cost of being rather fragile itself. They fill in the middle ground between Hunter and Titan, capable of dishing out plenty of pain one moment and providing support and resources for the other Guardians the next.

Despite each class being naturally geared to a specific type of combat, each class can be tweaked to your own personal preferences. Each Guardian class has two ‘Supers’ (think special moves) which they can equip, each with their own separate skill trees to level up. Only one ‘Super’ can be equipped at once, and they operate in an offensive/defensive pairing.

Destiny - Ward of Dawn

The Titan’s defensive Super in action – Ward of Dawn.

Through careful tweaking of each Super’s individual skill tree, all of the three classes can be largely customised to operate effectively in most combat roles, alone or as part of a fireteam (for the most part, fireteams are three-person max groups of players that you can adventure through the missions together as).

For example, you could design your normally slow and heavy Titan to be super quick and speedy at the cost of its armour, and likewise, you could tweak your normally fragile Warlock to be super tough and more bullet resistant at the cost of its speed and damage output. It’s all down to what works best for you. All guns can be used by all classes; however, some classes are naturally suited to wield certain weapon types over others, and will usually receive appropriate bonuses to their intended combat style through their class armour – for example, a Hunter’s armour will likely give boosts that support the use of sniper rifles, whilst a Titan’s armour will usually grant advantages with machine guns.

While it’s good that the classes are designed to be flexible in this way, unfortunately, this also means that when fully levelled up, each class can start to feel indifferent to each other. Combined with the fact that every class can wield every gun, and it soon becomes apparent that it’s not particularly important to have a balanced team of different skills and talents to overcome the alien hordes with; no, just make sure everyone in the fireteam brings their biggest and best guns and you’ll be just fine.

This isn’t a major problem as such, but it does undermine the idea of putting together a holy trinity of the three classes as a single cohesive combat unit – you’re just as likely to get through the same story mission with three armed to the teeth Warlocks as you are having a fireteam made up of all different classes. Oh, and speaking of the story missions…

Halo darkness my old friend…

Destiny - Hive Acolyte

A Hive Acolyte – far too close for comfort.

Remember earlier when I was telling you about Destiny‘s plot? The Traveller, The Darkness, evil space aliens, doom and gloom and all of that jazz – so far, so good right? Well, all of this is explained in the game’s opening cutscene. Make sure you’re paying attention to this cutscene, however, as that’s pretty much the extent of the story you’re going to get for the entire game! Yes, really!

This, to me, was personally my biggest disappointment with Destiny, and it’s something that I’m sure other players familiar with Bungie’s output over the years will pick up on pretty quickly when playing the game, so I thought I’d address it early on.

As a long-time Halo fan, I was both saddened and confused at how little the narrative barebones of this potentially very interesting plot set-up are actually fleshed out. In fact, upon getting about halfway through the game, despite seeing a few scant cutscenes here and there that might have at one point suggested otherwise, the horrifying realisation that no, there still isn’t anything resembling a story at this late stage felt very much like a brutal gut-punch to me as a player.

From the very start of the game, to the surprisingly quick end (the story mode can be played through in about 6-8 hours), I found myself asking largely the same old questions I had at the very beginning; What exactly is The Traveller? Why are there suddenly robots (the Exo) and shiny blue space elves (the Awoken) being nonchalantly classed as part of humanity as if we’ve always had them? Why have I not met any other significant characters yet? I know Bungie are planning to run and support this franchise for a decade, but come on, I need some characters and plot to go on in the meantime, or I’m just not going to have any real interest right now, let alone in ten years’ time.

Destiny - Mars City

The ruined cities of Mars. Despite finishing the story, I’ve still not got any idea as to how they actually got ruined unfortunately.

To be fair here, as much as I’ve loved the stories and plots of the wider Halo universe, the stories told in the Halo games haven’t exactly been the most original and ground-breaking things ever (the extra lore in the books and other media have expanded significantly on the small scope that the games cover, but that’s for another article). Yes, you’ve got the usual space marine clichés, and at times the cheesy military gung-ho attitude bursting forth at the game’s power armour clad seams might be a bit ridiculous, but the stories were delivered in a well polished manner and, like the Master Chief himself, stuck to their (many) guns, delivering a linear yet exciting dramatic space opera in the process.

However, I’m sure that even for those Destiny players who haven’t played the Halo series, the weak threads of Destiny‘s story will still be a bit of a major let-down to say the very least, no matter what your stance on narrative in games is.

 Letter of the lore

Destiny - Ghost Grimoire Card

The Grimoire Ghost Card. This is from the Destiny Companion App – you can’t access these from the game whatsoever right now.

As you play through Destiny, notices will pop up after killing enemies, collecting loot, completing story missions and finding items, saying that you’re unlocking new Grimoire cards. “But lo – what are these Grimoire cards of which you speak Reviewer?”, I hear you cry. Well, these cards are essentially lore cards that give extra information on the enemies, locations and weapons etc. that you’ll come across as you play through the game.

From what I’ve read myself, the lore itself is interesting and nicely ambiguous, and from what I’ve gathered from other players’ more extensive reading, there’s now some cool theories circulating online about just what exactly is going on in this sci-fi universe, and whether everything is as it narratively seems to be – but it’s all entirely separate from the actual game. There’s no way to access any of this content from within the game itself; you instead have to log into a Bungie.net account or fire up the Bungie Companion App to read your collection of lore cards, which seems like a massive oversight in my opinion. Even just having the utility to access your Grimoire cards in some out of the way options menu would have been adequate, but to make the player have to go and read up on the lore via a separate app, or through the Bungie.net website to get the story that didn’t make it into the final game seems like a really counter-intuitive decision.

Upon completing the main story missions, I’ve still not felt compelled to go back and read up on the lore, and this is coming from someone who has, overall, really enjoyed their time with Destiny. It’s a real shame, because at times, with the beautiful art direction, evocative soundtrack and the shared world social interactions between players, Destiny gets very close to capturing that sense of awe and wonder that Bungie really nailed when you first set your amour-clad foot upon the eponymous ringworld of Halo: Combat Evolved. There’s certainly plenty of mysteries out there in Destiny‘s universe, but you won’t be getting engrossed and drawn into them by playing the game at the moment, that’s for sure. Luckily, you won’t need to be.

Why Halo there

Destiny - Vex Minotaur

A Vex Minotaur, coming in close for some gentlemanly fisticuffs.

While Destiny has little to no story or characters, its real strength is in its engaging and satisfying gunplay. Anybody who’s played the Halo games will instantly feel right at home here; from the power and handling of the guns themselves with their thunderous reverberating gunshots, to the nuanced design, look and behaviours of the enemy alien species you’ll be riddling holes in with said powerful guns, the gun-toting gameplay in Destiny feels unmistakably Bungie, and thus, unmistakably fantastic.

Whilst the same unfortunately can’t be said for the story, the raw gameplay DNA of that defining first person shooter experience that Bungie pioneered in Halo: Combat Evolved is still delightfully intact and as satisfying as ever. It’s absolutely central to Destiny‘s genetic makeup. The gunplay is the key thing to what makes Destiny so compelling an experience – it’s rock solid and incredibly satisfying; it’s what will keep you coming back for more and more and more. The guns are all similar staples of ones found in the Halo universe; you’ve got such classics as all-out assault rifles, versatile three-burst pulse rifles, precise single shot DMR-like scout rifles, alongside fan favourite power weapons such as sniper rifles, shotguns and rocket launchers. Each gun has its own particular chunky feel, sound and weight, and you’ll amass a whole plethora of different armaments to mix and match with as you see fit on your inter-planetary jaunts.

The loot system is the other big draw, and it’s how you’ll be acquiring the vast majority of your weapons and gear in the game. For the most part, the loot drops work well for the majority of the game. All the loot in your game is unique to you; each player gets their own independent loot stream, which is a great design choice, as it means no more squabbling over who gets that shiny new gun or helmet a boss has dropped, as was prone to happen on a frequent basis in games like Diablo III or Borderlands 2. Although there are some flaws with the way the loot system works as you near the level-cap (more on this coming up later), generally, it works well.

Destiny - Cabal Combat

A full-frontal Cabal assault. In a word; painful.

The different enemy AIs are generally good; enemies usually require a good blend of strategy to overcome, and their decent AI programming for the most part stops them from feeling like simple bullet sponges. Destiny‘s enemies comprise four different alien races, each with their own unique abilities and tactics. Although all the four races have their own interesting combat strategies, weaknesses, enemy types and class hierarchies, it’s the last two you’ll encounter – the robotic Vex and the lumbering highly-armoured Cabal – that prove the most challenging and interesting to fight. The Cabal in particular are great for co-op play, as many of their troops carry impenetrable shields, requiring you to co-ordinate with your teammates and flank them in order to take them down successfully.

As the game is designed like an MMO however, with separate instances – an ‘instance’ is a term in MMOs for a specific portion of the world map that a particular bunch of players are currently in – when players move off, the enemies will routinely spawn back in and head back to predetermined spots, which undermines their otherwise good intelligence, and at times, can remind you that you’re not exactly playing a first person shooter or an MMO – it’s a blend of the two, a hybrid, which comes with definite pros and cons. In fact, as a result of this, at times, very predictable enemy behaviour, there’s now a growing number of players that have found so-called ‘loot caves’ to farm; places where enemies will constantly respawn over and over again after being killed, allowing players to repeatedly grind away, killing them repeatedly in the hope of acquiring loot at a faster pace than otherwise possible. It’s not a massive thing, but it does undermine the feeling somewhat that you’re playing against smart and responsive enemies from time to time.

Destiny - Vex Goblins Combat

A horde of pesky Vex Goblins. Vexing indeed.

Last but not least, with all this talk of good Halo-esque comparisons, the soundtrack deserves particular credit for building and sustaining Destiny‘s atmosphere. Martin O’Donnell’s superb scores work wonderfully well to establish the world and environments with atmosphere and character…which is just as well, as there are practically no other characters in the story aside from you and your Ghost, AKA the Dinkbot.

Game of drones

Destiny - Titan and Ghost

Guardian and Dinklebot; the ultimate duo in intergalactic crime fighting.

The Ghost is voiced by Game of Thrones actor Peter Dinklage, and he’s your main companion on your adventures throughout the solar system. In fact, with a couple of exceptions towards the end of the game, he’s practically the only other character you have any meaningful narrative interaction with.

As a result, there’s no foundation for any sort of character development at all. Try as you might, even your own Guardian feels rather bland once that post character creation buzz has worn off, no matter how many colourful robes, cool knee guards or amazing technicolour dreamcoats you swaddle them in.

I know it’s been parodied to death already on the internet, but I’ve got to bring it up if we’re talking about the Ghost – Peter Dinklage’s wooden delivery of his lines leaves you really wanting more. From my experience, yes, whilst it’s true that the Dinkbot isn’t the most charismatic companion that will ever accompany you across a virtual landscape, I feel that it’s the poor quality of the material that he’s got to work with that lets his performance down, and not his acting ability per se.

To bang on about it once again, with no other characters to significantly interact with, and with a great deal of the narrative stripped out of the game and put into the Grimoire cards as external lore, the weak writing is laid painfully bare, time and time again. Again, the universe and lore of Destiny is definitely intriguing; it’s just that so much of the plot development is relayed to you via big ungainly exposition dumps from Dinkbot, which you’ll quickly become tired with.

Also, despite Destiny‘s strong focus on continually connected online multiplayer, co-operative play and the shared stories that emerge from playing and interacting together, it’s strange that, on the rare occasions when you do get a story cutscene to watch, only your character is displayed, and none of your fellow fireteam members appear with you. It’s not a big thing, but nonetheless it is a bit jarring if you aren’t playing solo. Considering that arguably the absolute core tenet of the game is to join up with your fellow gamers and tackle the story’s villainous mobs of aliens together, it feels like a bit of a confusing misstep to isolate you from your friends during the cinematic moments.

Destiny - Ghost in Hand

“Fly me to the moon, let me…hover, among the stars…”

Apart from these very occasionally occurring cutscenes, most of the game is spent wandering around the various planetary vistas with your own personal robo-Dink in tow. Unfortunately, despite how beautiful these areas are, they feel lifeless and hollow; there’s nothing really going on in them apart from them being home to endlessly respawning monster closets – spewing out hordes of enemies every few minutes, which eagerly rush back into their set positions to once again be slain over and over again ad infinitum.

So, the weak story, combined with a very repetitive mission structure, begins to quickly feel stale and tired after only a few missions in. At times, Destiny‘s missions can be so formulaic in structure it’s laughable. A typical story mission usually goes as follows:

  1.  Start of mission. Cue a substantial exposition dump of woolly information/backstory from Dinkbot to set you on your way.
  2. Go to objective location.
  3. Kill enemies.
  4. Go to next area, cue more story waffle.
  5. Kill enemies in this location, go to new location.
  6. Kill last bunch of enemies, maybe slaying a few tougher enemies along the way and possibly even a boss character to finish.
  7. End of mission. Cue breakdancing and teabagging a plenty.
  8. Return to planetary orbit. Go to Tower. Cash in engrams with Cryptarch, cash in completed bounties, and buy new gear and supplies if neccessary.
  9. Head back into orbit, pick new destination and mission.
  10. Rinse and repeat.

On reflection though, perhaps it was naïve of me to go in expecting a story comparable to that of Halo‘s. Afterall, the game isn’t a straightforward singleplayer game, in a lot of ways, it’s more akin to an MMO in terms of its structure than a FPS. Once I shifted my perspective away from what I would normally hope to get from a typical FPS experience, and I thought about the game more along the lines of how an MMO operates, then I somewhat let my gripes about a lack of meaningful story slide a bit. To bring up Diablo III as a point of reference again, I absolutely loved that game for it’s great gameplay and didn’t so much as bat an eyelid at its dark and serious storyline, and the same applies here for Destiny. It’s not about what or why you’re doing the things you’re up to in Destiny, it’s about who you’re doing them with. Once you come to this epiphany of a realisation, the game really steps up a gear and comes to life.

A little help from my friends

Destiny - Guardians at Tower

Guardians at the Tower, ready to go off a-questin’.

Having played the game both solo and with friends, it’s pretty clear to say that Destiny is a far more engrossing adventure with other Guardians in your fireteam who are also along for the ride. The social shared world aspects of the game, and the ability to bump into friends and other adventuring players on your travels really transforms what otherwise might have been a bland regular shooter into something truly unique and fresh. A lack of local co-op is a tad disappointing, although it’s perhaps unsurprising considering the general direction of multiplayer in the industry these days, so you’ll need other online friends on the same platform to go on your merry loot hunting adventures with.

The Tower is possibly one of the greatest things about the game. It’s essentially the main game hub; you’ll use the Tower as a place where you can meet up with your friends, buy new gear, and decrypt engrams you find (think bright colourful footballs containing mystery gear) from the Cryptarch. You’re normally coming to and from the Tower with a specific purpose in mind, but some of the best moments are when you are just waiting around and mingling with the other players.

Mingling is easy; the D-pad lets you perform simple gestures, allowing you to communicate non-verbally with your fellow Guardians, including waves, points, sitting down (to show when you are AFC, or ‘Away From Console’) and, of course, dance routines; naturally, this leads to some daft player interactions. Seeing a mass breakdance party kick off in front of one of the Tower vendors is always funny, always unpredictable and always incredibly charming.

As much as these gestures are greatly entertaining ways of interacting with your fellow Guardians, it’s the spontaneous way that you will naturally stumble across other players going about their own business while out on your own individual missions that make the biggest impression.

Destiny - Sparrow Racing

The Sparrow, your Guardian’s very own Star Wars-esque speeder bike, makes getting across levels a real thrill.

The emergent stories that arise from players coming across each other out in the wilds of the shared worlds are some of my own personal highlights from the game, and I imagine it’s this sort of storytelling that Bungie is counting on players experiencing when they go off adventuring as a fireteam.

When these special moments of spontaneous player interaction happen, they feel nothing short of magical. At their very best, you can experience some spur of the moment instances that feel like something carefully scripted, something you might expect to find in expansive and detailed open world games like Fallout 3, Grand Theft Auto and Red Dead Redemption.

On one occasion, after wandering off the beaten path on a basic story mission on the Moon, I soon found myself lost deep within the Hive-infested tunnels below the surface. Think wandering around in the mines of Morria from The Lord of The Rings, only with space zombies, space knights and a cave troll-like Ogre that can rapid-fire lasers from its face, and you’re in the right ball park.

Destiny - Hive Ogre

Fee-fi-fo-RUN!

I fought for my virtual life throughout these gloomy dank catacombs for absolutely ages, hoping to find some secrets or perhaps just another way out, only to be greeted at every turn by hordes and hordes of enemies keen to make my acquaintance. This felt wonderfully oppressive (as strange as that sounds) and it created a heavy atmosphere of desperation, horror and dread that managed to draw me into the game world in a visceral and gripping way that the story completely failed to do. Being lost and on your own in a game normally swarming with other players makes you feel anxious yet electrifyingly engaged.

It took a long time, and an awful lot of bullets, but I eventually found a way out. Upon finally stumbling back outside onto the dusty lunar plains, my relief at seeing other players milling about and merrily dancing around each other was such a sublime moment of release. After being truly alone for a good hour or so, it’s hard to express how special it felt to be around other players again – it’s easy to take the shared experience feel of the game world for granted.

Destiny - Vex Goblins Combat 2

“I’m, too Vex-y for my shirt…erm, power armour.”

Another time, I was making my way through the Aztec-like ruins on the planet Venus (as you do) when I stumbled across a large group of players fighting off swarms of teleporting Vex machines. At first I had no idea what they were doing, but they were getting bombarded on all sides, so feeling the pull of bystander intervention, I shouldered my auto rifle and joined the fray. As it turned out, this was a raiding group I had stumbled across, and they were currently in the process of raising a spire to gain access to the Vault of Glass – Destiny’s first raid mission. Although I was a tad underlevelled in comparison to the rest of the group, I lent my firepower to their cause, helping them to hold the incoming Vex troopers off whilst defending the spire platforms in order to get the massive vault door open. It was an absolutely exhilarating battle to have just spontaneously walked into off the cuff. Sadly, although I couldn’t progress further into the Vault of Glass with them, it felt incredibly satisfying to have played a bit part in helping them on their way.

The Crucible

Destiny - Crucible Team Shot

Guardians strutting their stuff in the Crucible. I’m the one holding the flag – the team mascot, in other words.

Once you feel like you’ve slain your fair share of gruesome space ogres and time-travelling robotic war machines for the day, it’s time to kick back and head into the Crucible for a while. This is Destiny‘s PVP mode, where Guardians can battle each other for experience points, Crucible marks (one of the game’s special currencies) and, of course, fancy loot.

While perhaps not the most unique competitive multiplayer experience out there, the Crucible is fast-paced, exhilarating and a lot of fun. Most importantly though, it’s simplicity makes it a very accessible place to start for those who might otherwise not have bothered with a competitive shooter experience before.

The interplay between the Crucible and the regular co-op missions works brilliantly. Bungie have wisely allowed players to decide how and what they want to play in Destiny, gently encouraging them to try new experiences without forcing players into a painful grind in modes that they won’t enjoy.

Everything applies back to your character, so any cool gear or guns you earn in one mode can be used to help you out in another. All the gear and guns you earn in the game work in both PVP and PVE modes, so all the progress and rewards you earn in the Crucible you can carry over and use in the co-operative story mode also. I personally found this to be incredibly appealing; I’m not the biggest competitive shooter fan, so I’ve naturally spent the majority of my time in Destiny in the co-operative modes. But being able to bring across my favourite guns and gear from the story to the Crucible and vice versa definitely makes a big difference to me, and it gives an added incentive to jump into the Crucible from time to time to see how I measure up to the other Guardians.

Although players are complaining that the competitive multiplayer doesn’t completely balance out weapon stats – the game apparently only balances out the basic stats, and not some of the additional special effects the legendary and exotic weapons come with – I’ve personally not come across this problem myself. From my own experience of the Crucible, regularly playing at different experience levels with different combinations of weapons and gear, I found that, much like other competitive games with ranking systems, a player’s number or rank is just an indicator of how long they’ve been playing the game, and this doesn’t necessarily correlate to their true skill. Unless you’re playing an Iron Banner event (a special limited availability competitive mode that was playable in the Beta, where gear and gun advantages aren’t levelled out), then generally you don’t have to worry about other players having unfair advantages over you; the Crucible still manages to be a fair test of player skill for the most part, and an enjoyable PVP alternative to the story/co-op missions.

High level competitive first person shooter players have voiced their complaints at the lack of private lobbies however, and the lack of other features that they’ve come to expect from similar competitive online first person shooter games, so unless these are patched in quickly, the game will likely not catch on significantly in the pro/e-sports communities.

Light at the end of the (ambiguously long) tunnel

Destiny - Glimmer Chest

Loot, glorious loot.

With all these story missions and Crucible matches under your belt, you’ll soon find your Guardian levelling up at a delightfully fast rate. The upgrades come thick and fast, and you’ll have amassed a decent pile of guns and gear in your inventory. In fact, levelling up happens so fast, that you’ll find yourself at the level max rather more quickly than you may have anticipated.

Destiny has a relatively low experience level ‘soft-cap’ which can be reached with only a few hours on the clock. Although this itself isn’t necessarily a bad thing – the level cap of 20 has been repeatedly stated by the developers to be only the start of things with regard to the end-game activities – this is by all means a relatively low level cap in comparison to other big loot and grinding games such as, you guessed it, Borderlands 2 and Diablo III. Reaching the cap in those games can take hundreds of hours of play, whereas you’ll reach level 20 in Destiny in a mere fraction of that time.

Obviously, just having to grind for grinding’s sake does not a good game make, but your climb up the experience ladder in Destiny will most likely feel a bit anticlimactic to say the least. Combined with a relatively small number of unique missions and things to do, this does leave a bit of a bitter question mark hanging over the player’s head, with an unpleasant lingering notion of “Is that really it?” Well…not quite.

Destiny - Light Ratings

Finding gear with more light requires both patience and luck…lots of luck.

I say there’s a soft-cap of 20, because in actual fact, you can go past it. To level up past 20, you need to start acquiring wearable armour and gear for your character that have ‘light’ in them. This appears as a new statistic on the wearable gear you’ll find going forward, which you’ll need to move up into the post-20 levels (level 30 being the final cap for the time being). It’s at this point that the loot system goes from working nicely to being a cheap lucky-dip apple bobbing contest in a hand cannon’s muzzle flash.

The loot, armour and guns you’ll find while playing and that you’ll receive as mission rewards are, as far as I can tell, entirely luck based. You’ll still earn experience points as you did before, but once you’re at level 20, they only count towards levelling up your currently equipped gear, special ability and guns. From here on out, it’s totally down to lady luck as to if and when you get gear with better light ratings. Get a high enough light rating from your gear and you’ll go up a level. Don’t find anything with higher light ratings and, well…you could be stuck there for some time, and there’s nothing you can do about it except to get that plucky nose of yours back to the grindstone. All of a sudden, this turns levelling up from a smooth gradual incline of progress into a jagged stop-start purgatory-like traffic jam.

Destiny - Cryptarch

The Cryptarch. Helping and scamming players in equal measure. Somebody call Watchdog…

In fact, in some ways, the loot system is actually currently broken in a few key ways. Remember a whole bunch of paragraphs ago when I was saying that the system works well for the most part? Well, it does, but as you’re levelling up and playing the game, you’ll be dealing with this friendly blue chap in the tower called the Cryptarch. You might even come to grow fond of him; he’s an elderly Awoken mystic who is only too eager to help turn those glowing colourful engram balls you’ve hoarded into shiny new things for you to use on your next cosmic adventure.

For the majority of your game, you’ll be turning in green and blue engrams, which, by and large, give green (uncommon) and blue (rare) items, as you might expect from their corresponding colour scheme. However, once you’ve reached the level cap, you’ll be starting to find your first purple (legendary) engrams, which as the name suggests, you would think to contain legendary items. Nope. What it actually means is that it could be a legendary item…but it probably won’t be.

You might have been grinding for hours to get that purple engram, but there’s no guarantee you’ll actually get a legendary gun or piece of armour from it once it’s decoded. Needless to say, this can feel very cheap and frustrating – which, like I briefly mentioned earlier, has lead to a bunch of Destiny players spending all day farming loot caves in the hope of lucking out on rare items. This is apparently being patched by Bungie in an upcoming update to make sure that you definitely get the correct level of loot from the engrams you turn in, but it’s made advancing through the levels for current Destiny players a bit of a chore in the meantime.

Essentially, once you’re at the soft-cap the loot system degenerates into a game of chance. At level 20 and beyond, whether you’re playing in The Crucible or carrying out story/co-op missions, you’re playing with your fingers crossed at all times, hoping that any loot you come across has more light. There’s no other way to progress.

With all this chance involved in getting past the soft-cap, you might well ask “What’s the point in doing all this extra levelling up past 20? If it’s all down to luck, why spend hours grinding trying to go any further?” Well, it becomes particularly important if you want to experience the end-game content such as the raids. These are the key features of the game that Bungie are keen to impress upon players as the best bits of the entire Destiny experience.

Raiding between the lines

Destiny - Devil Walker

The fearsome Fallen Devil Walker can be a particularly tough nut to crack.

Raids are particularly difficult missions that require a team of six players to come together and tackle gruelling enemies and massive bosses, much like MMO raid players do in games like World of Warcraft, in order to get their hands on some of the most rare and powerful loot and weapons in the game for their characters. Raid missions require fireteams to have unrivalled communication skills, co-operation and teamwork in order to pull off these most difficult of missions successfully.

Here’s why levelling up is important past the soft-cap. It’s suggested that players need to be at least level 26 minimum to be in a decent position to start tackling the raids, and about level 28 in order to competently take part. The bottom line; these raids are pretty damn hard. To even begin thinking about tackling a raid before getting to the higher post-20 level is pretty much suicide, hence why you’ll need to spend a good portion of time beforehand grinding away for better gear, and hoping you’ll chance across enough decent gear with light in it.

Destiny‘s apparently hard-as-nails endgame content sounds terribly exciting. I say ‘apparently’, and ‘sounds terribly exciting’, because as of yet, I haven’t been able to play them. I’m essentially twiddling my virtual thumbs as I wait for my friends to level up. I’m a level 26 Titan myself (lucky me), but I’ve got to wait for my five other friends to have the same luck with light-filled loot that I’ve had, because here’s a bombshell – there’s no matchmaking system in place for the raids, and the weekly heroic/nightfall challenges (these are also pretty tough).

This means that unless you have five other highly-levelled and tooled-up friends playing Destiny, you won’t be able to get access to arguably some of the best gameplay and experiences that the game has to offer.

Why offer extensive and technically impressive matchmaking systems throughout the majority of Destiny, only to snatch them away for what are supposed to be the best bits of your game? In fact, as far as I’m aware, the game doesn’t actually tell you anywhere how to start up your own in-game clan (Destiny‘s integrated online team system, designed to help you organise raid dates and times etc. with all of your clan members as a whole). I’m only aware of the clan system and how it works from my previous experience with Bungie’s Halo clan systems over the years. I can only imagine that there’s going to be lots of people out there who won’t ever get to experience what’s touted as Destiny‘s best content as it’s not sufficiently explained to them in-game.

Destiny - Sepiks Prime

Sepiks Prime – AKA that giant electric floating eyeball thing, is also quite a brute on the harder difficulties.

I’ve found from my own personal experience with Bungie’s Halo games that they can be particularly heavy-handed when it comes to how they want you to play their games online. I can totally understand why they want you to just solely play the raids with people you have in your clan/friends list to some extent – you’re more likely to talk and communicate with people you know, players are less likely to unexpectedly drop out, and overall you’ll generally be more comfortable and more likely to get into the heat of the action as you navigate through these difficult dungeons together, where real-time tactics and communication are no doubt keys to success.

Friends-only raiding is absolutely a nice idea in some ways, but it feels impractical, and very prescriptive considering how open and flexible the rest of the game is. Bungie’s stance on the raids, unfortunately, seems to be unnecessarily difficult and officious. It’s like trying to get into a nightclub with a particularly stubborn bouncer on the door, who point blank refuses to let you in for some petty reason, even though you’re obeying the dress code and being perfectly charming.

They seem to have this overblown romantic idea of how you’re supposed to be playing alongside your online friends. You and these fine, brave men and women you’ve banded together with on your epic journey; these noble warriors of old, armour clad and powerful, standing tall with the galaxy’s finest weaponry in their hands.

Actually, no, not quite – I just want to play a raid for a few hours if that’s quite all right Bungie? Pretty please? I would of course prefer to play with my friends when possible, but I’d also like to just jump into a raid with strangers from time to time and see how we all get on if my online gaming friends aren’t available. Is that too much to ask Big Brother?

Does it really matter if we fail hopelessly at a raid? Can I not be allowed to try and fail on my own terms? I couldn’t care less if I repeatedly failed, or the team doesn’t communicate properly, or we just simply can’t pull it off in the end because people want to breakdance all the time – isn’t it the taking part that counts after all? Anyway, enough of these rhetoricals – to the Batcave! No wait, that’s not right – to the conclusion!

To Infinity, and beyond

Destiny - Ship Vortex

Set the controls for the heart of the sun…actually, on second thought, let’s go back to Earth instead.

So that’s Destiny, in an admittedly rather large planetary-sized nutshell. The game is fantastic and ground breaking in a lot of ways, but it has so many critical problems at its foundation. Some of these are just so inconceivably basic, especially so when you consider the amount of money that was reportedly pumped into the game – a whopping $500 million was the original (later said to be inaccurate) figure.

As a result, you’ll find yourself asking, “How did they manage to get this so wrong?” at times, only to be blown away mere seconds later by some ridiculously exciting spontaneous event that kicks off and gets everybody in the area playing together and having a genuinely good time. There’s moments where you’ll be truly amazed by what’s going on in Destiny, marvelling at how fresh and exciting this socially connected playing space is, only to find out how fragile and stale it is in places, like an abandoned flimsy cardboard film set, with no actors in sight for miles.

Despite the flaws, I’ve thoroughly enjoyed my time in Destiny, and I plan on spending many more hours looting and shooting my way back and forth across the solar system for a long time yet. In terms of new content coming to the game over in the near future, there’s two paid expansion packs that have been announced as part of the Destiny Season Pass – The Dark Below and House of Wolves, with another two unannounced packs to follow, and free updates and patches for the game are rolling out on a pretty regular basis, so you clearly feel that the game has a great deal of support right from the off.

For me though, when I think about Destiny, it’s all about the guns and gameplay. The shooting mechanics in Destiny are an example of Bungie at it’s finest – from the moment you pick up that first ancient and rusted assault rifle in Old Russia, you know you’re in for something special. So special, in fact, that longtime Bungie fans will swear that they’re holding their gun in some very familiar green MJOLNIR power armoured hands.

Destiny - Green Titan

Cough, cough *Master Chief* cough cough.

Destined for greatness with its solid gunplay and next-gen co-op and social features, but significant flaws with the story and loot system prevent Destiny from truly becoming legend.

Pros Cons
+ Gunplay is fantastic. – Story is a complete mess.
+ Hunting for loot is exciting and addictive. – The action gets very repetitive, very quickly
+ Shared world areas lend themselves to moments of fantastic spontaneity and player interaction. – No matchmaking for key modes in an always-online multiplayer game is baffling.

6 thoughts on “Destiny Review

  1. Eva Rowe

    What a great review! I think you bring up some good questions. Who is the mysterious stranger who gives you the guy? Have you figure that out yet if you have I would like to know your thoughts on who she is! Again what a great review and I will definitely be back to you blog!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for reading Eva! 🙂

      I’ve no idea who Xur is actually – I don’t think there was much about him in the Grimoire from what I’ve briefly read, but I’m sure that there will be some hidden meaning or significance to his character as time goes on. If I come across any good nuggets of into, I’ll be sure to let you know though! Thanks again for the kind words, much appreciated.

      Tom 🙂

      Like

      • Eva Rowe

        Tom I meant to say who is the stranger who gives you the gun not the guy! Lol Need to proof read better before I post

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s